Why we need to stop lecturing young men about the manosphere

Stop lecturing young men about the manosphere. Help them be part of the solution

Stop lecturing young men about the manosphere. Help them be part of the solution

Many young men can already spot the toxic stuff in their feeds. Our job is to turn that instinct into the skills and values to reject it

I RECENTLY STOOD in front of an auditorium full of Year 9 boys and asked whether they felt in control of their algorithm. Every hand went up. Every single one.

I had to stifle a laugh. These are 14-year-olds who, social media ban or not, are scrolling feeds tuned by some of the best-paid engineers on the planet, and they were certain they were choosing what they saw. That certainty may be the most useful thing we know about boys online. Our new research from the Movember Institute of Men’s Health gives it depth, and suggests it doesn’t fade with age.

We asked 142 young men (16-25 in Australia, the UK and the US) about the masculinity content on their TikTok feeds. We never mentioned the manosphere. Many brought it up anyway. These young men are not the hollow vessels of the moral panic we keep reading about. A few were all in and more rejected it outright, but most sat somewhere in between: taking the gym tips and money advice while calling out the misogyny that came packaged with them. Some called influencers cringe, vain and desperate for fame. A 19-year-old from the US described the whole machine in a sentence: it “misguide[s] young men down incel/alt right thinking through the guise of life coaching/motivation.”

Yet almost all of them located vulnerability in someone else: younger boys, lonelier boys, boys who’d just been dumped. Hardly anyone thought the hook was in them. A 22-year-old Australian was the rare one who placed himself in the frame: “I don’t want to be a part of it because it’s messed up, but just a little I want to be like that so I feel respected or at least deserving of it.”

The manosphere doesn’t need young men to agree with it. It needs them to want something, and they do, to be fitter, more confident, less broke, less alone. The contempt for women comes in the same package, usually dressed up as a joke. A 21-year-old described boys heartbroken for the first time hitting the gym to feel better and being served misogyny with their deadlift form: “Although they may get ripped, their internal issues will never get fixed.”

That is the mental health story underneath all this. Content that promises confidence works by first convincing you you’re short of it. One 18-year-old described turning to this content on days he felt low, precisely when algorithms tend to serve harder material. Self-improvement slides quickly into risk: day trading and gambling sold as the route to wealth, looksmaxxing that starts with jawline tips and ends with steroids, peptides and bonesmashing. Our previous research links this content to psychological distress, body-image anxiety and dangerous health behaviours in young men. The algorithm promises a cure for feeling inadequate, but it needs young men to feel worse in order to keep buying what it’s selling.

Our usual response is to tell them off. We warn, we lecture, we ban, and we’re surprised when they tune out. Teenage boys push back hard on anything that feels like control, and telling a 15-year-old his feed is poisoning him is a near-guaranteed way to make him defend it.

Their belief that they’re in charge is partly an illusion. It also tells us what they value: self-determination. Most of this content isn’t black and white, and young men need help working through the grey, not a list of banned names. That means making the harms impossible to miss while backing the potential that drew them in. Wanting to be fitter, richer, braver or more disciplined is not the problem.

It also means helping them work out what they actually value, so the critical voice many already have gets louder. This is rubbish, I don’t want it in my feed, it’s not who I am. A boy who knows what kind of man he wants to be doesn’t need an adult to tell him the guy selling contempt for women isn’t it. Simple questions will help that muscle grow. Why did this video land in my feed now? Who makes money when I feel angry, inadequate or behind? And what is the guy telling me how to be a man selling on the side?

There’s a lesson for adults in that Year 9 room too. When the boys got to ask questions, nearly every one was about a person. What did I think of this influencer, or that one? They learned that from us. Every breathless profile of Andrew Tate tells boys the story is the loudest man in the room, not the business model that pays him. The business model is the real story, which is why the “My Feed, My Way” algorithm opt-out, now before parliament, could provide the starting point for these guys to feel empowered and in control, but it can’t be packaged as another adult rule from on high.

If we want young men to help fix this, we have to treat them as people capable of thinking critically about the world, including the version of it on their phones. Many of them know when they’re being sold snake oil, hatred, violence. Our job is to back that confidence with the skills, and the values, to match.

Dr Zac Seidler is Global Director of Men’s Health Research at the Movember Institute of Men’s Health


Related:

Dr Zac Seidler on why men have a crucial role to play if we are to effectively tackle domestic violence

We told men to be present fathers. Then we handed them the bill

By Dr Zac Seidler

In one of our most important pillars, we’re thrilled to be able to draw on the knowledge and expertise of Dr Zac Seidler, a clinical psychologist and senior research fellow at the University of Melbourne’s Orygen Institute and global director of men’s mental health research at Movember. Seidler, who’s dedicated his academic and professional career toward understanding men’s mental health and masculinity, ultimately aims to reduce the rate of male suicide.

More From