The NRL’s Pride Jersey Debacle Illustrates A Far Bigger Problem Within Sport - Men's Health Magazine Australia

The NRL’s Pride Jersey Debacle Illustrates A Far Bigger Problem Within Sport

As more players from Manly Sea Eagles joined the revolt to not wear a jersey featuring an inclusive strip, the issue serves to reinforce the issue of diversity that lies at the heart of such sporting codes.

When the Manly Sea Eagles made the announcement this week that players would wear a rainbow strip on their jersey during the game against the Sydney Roosters as a means of promoting LGBTQI+ inclusion in rugby league, the backlash came swiftly. Seven players immediately told the club that they would stand down from the match, citing religious and cultural beliefs as the reason why they would not wear the jersey.

News of such a response from players was quick to divide loyal fans and the public alike. The large majority however, could only condemn such a response and for the devastating message it would send to those within the LGBTQI+ community, regardless of whether they are sporting enthusiasts, up-and-coming NRL players, or those simply looking to see themselves represented in greater facets of society. 

Manly became the first club to ever introduce a pride jersey, and fans were in favour of such inclusivity. After it was made public that players were standing down from participating in the match, fans expressed their support and solidarity with the LGBTQI+ community, with the jerseys selling out in mens’ sizes online within hours of the player boycott. 

After holding an emergency meeting with the players in question, the decision has since been made by the club to go into battle on Thursday night without Josh Aloiai, Jason Saab, Christian Tuipulotu, Josh Schuster, Humble Olakau’atu, Tolutau Koula and Toafofoa Sipley. Coach Des Hasler told the Sydney Morning Herald that he supports their decision to stand down, while journalist Paul Kent was quick to defend the players, condemning the club for trying to inject its own political views on the team. “Top inflict their own political views on the players who may not share that and are now being forced to deal with the consequences of that is a real oversight by the club and it’s something they should be embarrassed about,” he told NRL 360. 

But for Sea Eagles great, Ian Roberts, who became the first rugby league player to come out as openly gay, the decision of the seven players is one he found devastating. “I try to see it from all perspectives but this breaks my heart,” Roberts told the Daily Telegraph. “It’s sad and uncomfortable. As an older gay man, this isn’t unfamiliar. I did wonder whether there would be any religious pushback. That’s why I think the NRL have never had a Pride round.”

p.p1 {margin: 0.0px 0.0px 12.0px 0.0px; font: 12.0px Times; color: #000000}

“I can promise you, every young kid on the northern beaches who is dealing with their sexuality would have heard about this.”

Ian roberts

Hasler has since fronted the media to apologise for what he called a “poor” execution of what was “intended to be an extremely important initiative.” Even so, the saga extends beyond this incident alone and serves to illustrate the issue of inclusivity in a sport that has been far from the model of diversity. Despite the NRL’s 2017 inclusion framework stating: “We welcome everyone to rugby league, regardless of race, colour, religion, ability, creed, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, ancestry, or age. We proudly and publicly stand against intolerance and bigotry, and will actively campaign against it,” it seems that not enough is being done to promote greater inclusion and indeed foster such environments in sport. 

As Megan Maurice makes an argument for in The Guardian, LGBTIQI+ are at a greater disadvantage, with religious organisations and alcohol and gambling companies holding far more societal and financial power, making it harder for “individual players to stand against this power and ask for special consideration.”

Maurice offers a roadmap for how such initiatives within the league can be approached better in the future, with greater education and compassion from the outset, such as engaging Roberts to address the playing group about his experiences as a gay man in rugby league and giving the players who hold such religious objections within the club, the chance to explain their reluctance with a mediator between the two groups allowing for greater understanding of the challenges each face to work towards a solution. 

Hasler offered an apology to the LGBTQI+ community, saying: “For any person struggling with identity, we acknowledge the challenges and difficulties. My heart goes out to you and your families, and if the club can personally do anything to assist, we will. We are here, we offer our complete support. I apologise to anyone to whom this matter has caused distress.”

But as Maurice writes, “These are heartfelt words, but how much comfort would they provide to a young rugby league fan struggling with their identity?” 

If anything has emerged from the Manly Sea Eagles jersey saga, it’s that sport must do better when it comes to creating a safe space for all – regardless of sexual orientation. 

More From

Gather Round
Faultless footy, cutting-edge cars, and an atmosphere like no other: a weekend in Adelaide for Gather Round

Faultless footy, cutting-edge cars, and an atmosphere like no other: a weekend in Adelaide for Gather Round

If there’s one thing Adelaide is known for, it’s turning it on when major events and festivals come to town. During the 2024 edition of the AFL’s Gather Round – otherwise known as the festival of footy – the city didn’t disappoint. Men’s Health was on the ground to soak it all up, exploring the city in select Toyota vehicles. Similar to the round itself, the cars from the AFL’s premier partner live up to the hype.

Nico Hülkenberg
Nico Hülkenberg isn’t slowing down

Nico Hülkenberg isn’t slowing down

As one of the most experienced drivers on the grid, Haas veteran and Heinemann partner Nico Hülkenberg has seen Formula 1 rise to the top of international sports. He tells Men’s Health why F1 has never been more entertaining, what makes Aussie fans some of the world’s best, and why, after a golden career, he has no intention of slowing down any time soon